Cheque overpayment scam targets psychologists and therapists
Email scammers using a variation of the 419 scam have started targeting professionals such as therapists and interpreters.
A couple of days ago I received this email:
How are you and how has your week been? Wonderful I guess. I am Fredrick Pawlak a businessman and a single parent working temporarily in Singapore. I was searching for Therapist in Australia so I came across your advert on the Web.
My son has heightened fears about people, objects or situations, which He cannot face. Moreso, He continually feels low, most often with many complicated symptoms like poor sleep, negativity, deep anger, self-depression. So after a Phone Conversation with our Family Friend who is still on Vacation, He suggested that My son needs to visit a Therapist.
So I intend sending Him over to come and spend some time in Australia as soon as possible that will be more like an excursion. But during the time in which He will be spending over there which will be most probably for 4 weeks or more, I will want Him to Visit a Therapist.
Therefore, I want to know if you can be of any help to Us.
1. Your Theraphy Approaches.
2. Your Consultation charges / Durations.
These information are needed so that I would decide how many times in a week he would come for Consultations. Payment would be made in advance before my son’s arrival because I wish to send him over there in 2 to 3 weeks time from now. I anticipate your swift response. Do have a great day ahead and my humble regards to you and your loved ones.
Greetings,
Fredrick Pawlak
fredpawlak@yahoo.co.uk
+447024099618
The language struck me as somewhat idiosyncratic, but not unlikely if the writer was someone for whom English is a second language – a reasonable assumption to make given the surname used. When I get enquiries for assistance with mental health problems from people outside my registration jurisdiction (i.e. the state of Victoria, Australia), I usually suggest the person contact their local Psychology association or registration or licensing board. However, like any compassionate professional dealing with the parent of a young person in distress, I didn’t want to put the gentleman writing to me through any more trouble than necessary. And for all I knew, he had fairly plausible reasons for not seeking help in Singapore or the UK: lack of local knowledge, distance, in the case of Singapore perhaps a lack of depth in the local practice community.
Consequently I replied to the email explaining my usual preference to talk with the “identified client” before giving a firm undertaking to proceed with an appointment. About eight hours later, I received this reply:
Hello Julian,
How are you and how has your day been? Wonderful I guess. Thanks for your swift response and I am so glad to read from with the detailed information. As I have earlier written, My son who is 19 years of Age and he speaks english fluently so i think it would be of great advantage to communication. He has heightened fears about people despite his Age, situations which He cannot face, and He continually feels low, most often with many complicated symptoms like poor sleep, negativity, deep anger, self-depression.
After reading your mail, I would prefer a Consultation of 60minutes a day and it would be held 2 times a week at your own scheduled time.
I am willing that I make the arrangements with you prior to His arrival because next week most probably, I will be leaving Singapore for some important business obligation. I am making contacts with a professional guardian who will be His driver throughout this Excursions / Consultations. He will be bringing Him over for the Consultation on the scheduled days. I hope to establish a contact between you and Him as soon as possible. Below are my own calculations for payment:AU$XX0 for a Consultation / 60mins
i.e. AU$XX0 x 2 time in a week = AU$XX0
i.e. AU$XX0 x 4 weeks = AU$XX0
Total Approx = AU$XXX0
I would Issue out an Upfront payment of AU$XXX0 before His arrival, so I want to know if it is OK. I expect to read from you with the following information so that I can have my Financier issue out the payment on my behalf.Full Name: -
Full Contact Address: -
Phone Number {Home & Mobile}: -
Age: -Please, I will want to count on you for this because I am a very busy person, I am doing this as part of my responsibility towards my children because I am a single parent and I hardly have time for them. I want to plead with you to make this a successful and adventurous Excursion / Consultation for my son.
Anticipating your swift response. Have a wonderful weekend ahead and my humble regards to you and your loved ones.
Kind Regards,
Fredrick Pawlak..Address: – XXXXX XXXXXX#01-02,
XX XXXX XXXX Street, XXXXX, Singapore
The offer to pay upfront was the giveaway. I had indicated in my email that we might not go further than the first two or three sessions if I judged that my approach was unlikely to benefit the “client” – a precaution I routinely put in place when starting with a new client. So why the urgency to pay upfront for the whole episode?
To reassure myself that the enquiry was genuine, I googled the writer’s name. Nothing. So next I searched for phrases from the email. When I fed some of the details into 419scam.org it showed that the phone number, which I assumed was a UK-based landline, was in fact a UK-registered mobile which would divert to another country. Jackpot! Thanks to Google Translate I was able to establish that German interpreters had been targeted earlier this year using a similar approach: an urgent requirement for work to be done over a brief period with payment upfront.
The way this particular scam works is that the fraudsters overpay you with a dud cheque or traveller’s cheque. Then before you cash it or draw on it and find out it’s worthless, they contact you requiring you to urgently refund them the overpayment amount. Enough honest people will fall for this that it’s worth their while sifting through the ones who ignore the initial approach or delay reimbursing the overpayment until the cheque has cleared.
Takeaway message
Vet your clients before you book them in.
Insist on a phone contact (for your own safety do this in preference to face-to-face meetings) before agreeing to take on a client who has contacted you via email.
If someone offers to pre-pay sessions and wants to send funds via the web, or for that matter to post cheques to you, ensure it’s for only one or two sessions, and then wait for the funds to be drawable in your account before you do anything like refund an overpayment.
And finally, if you suspect anything is too good to be true or it just ‘feels wrong’ search www.419scam.org or in Australia www.scamwatch.gov.au for phrases or email addresses and phone numbers from the emails you’ve received.
Posted: August 14th, 2010 under Administration, Therapy and Counseling.
Comments: 6
Comments
Comment from Lynda
Time: August 14, 2010, 11:43 pm
Thanks for this. I have been approached and drawn in but wondered because of the language, but also because of the fact that he gave such clinical details of his son’s difficulties – clients don’t usually have the clinical language to describe symptoms this way.
Anything ingenuine in emails needs checking out, if any notice is to be taken.
I pondered on the same professional ethics as well, but wanted to talk with the son via phone before even a first visit. The secondary ethics are that the father is paying for treatment yet has no rights to know anything about the treatment due to client confidentiality. His son is supposed to be 19, so an independent adult.
I too felt for the parent, but what about the rights of the (as yet unheard) son to get help? If he had been genuine, there was something of an ethical push to NOT ignore the plea for help. That was what influenced me to even reply – there appeared to be an adolescent male suffering and requiring help, a high suicide risk due to age and gender…
The ingenuine move to talking in clinical terms was what mafe me sit up.
Thanks for tracking this scam down.
Comment from Ben Mullings
Time: August 15, 2010, 12:58 am
The other way is to get them to do payments via PayPal, with the booking confirmed only once the payment has been received. This is the way I do it with Internet counselling sessions. In the case you described it would mean that I would have been able to just refund the person automatically via PayPal’s system.
Nice work spotting this one!
Comment from Julian McNally
Time: August 16, 2010, 1:08 am
Thanks Ben and Lynda,
Ben I use PayPal that way too for people I haven’t met F2F and would have done with this guy if he was genuine. Interesting, It’s now more than 48 hours since his first contact with me and I’ve heard nothing from him (found another therapist? The son had a miraculous recovery?
)
Lynda – good to hear I wasn’t the only person ‘sucked in’ at least initially! I’d learned to take the same precautions as you with concerned parents and partners who think they have secured the “client’s” commitment to therapy but then it disappears when the “client” has to phone or actually attend the appointment. Result: embarrassment and frustration for the concerned relative and wasted time for the therapist.
Comment from Hetha Collin
Time: August 19, 2010, 2:59 am
Thanks Lynda, Ben & Julian for your responses. I was approached by the same email as well and I replied to the “father’s emails” for the same reasons you quoted. As you described it felt somehow weird and I also did a google search on the father with no results – except today when I found your responses about the email scam . The father added 3 photos, 2of himself with his sons (gorgeous shots) and one of himself (!?) a good looking man who appeared to be of European descent. I was told that an upfront payment cheque would be sent to my practice address and that his son would contact me via email . He didn’t yet although the first session should have been today!
Has anybody of you worked with the son and if yes, for how many sessions? What a way to get treated!! It shows, my gut feeling was right that something doesn’t match up but I got drawn in. Did you send an email back to “the father” about the scam?
Thank you for going “public”.
Comment from Mike Reeves-McMillan
Time: November 5, 2010, 9:41 am
Thanks for putting this up – I just received the identical email except for minor details. It sounded enough like the Nigerian scams to trigger my caution, so I Googled the name before replying – glad I did, and glad you reported your experience so I could be sure it’s not genuine.
Comment from Claire Buckley
Time: November 6, 2010, 4:47 am
I received the same email. Alarm bells rang and although I googled the name before I replied, it didn’t come back with anything – but then I got the email from Mike which confirmed my suspicions- thanks Mike!
Write a comment